Make Your Own Jamocha Shake

Every so often I give in to my craving for an Arby’s Jamocha shake. If you’ve never had one before, it’s a tasty little ice cream concoction with a subtle coffee/mocha flavor. We gave this copycat recipe for a Jamocha shake a try at our house yesterday to see if this could be an economical way to get the same flavors in our own kitchen.

Make Your Own Jamocha Shake

It Has To Be Thick
The first thing we noticed was that while the flavor was really close, our consistency was off. This is an important part of a good shake. If it’s not thick and creamy, it just doesn’t work. Maybe our ice cream was too soft, or maybe we ran the blender too long. I was almost wishing I had skipped the blender completely and just stirred it up in a mixing bowl!

Other Variables
The recipe also calls for a cup of cold coffee.  I’m not much of a coffee drinker and I think my coffee may have been a smidge too weak.  This recipe might do even better with a good strong brew.  The original recipe I followed also called for 3 tablespoons of sugar.  That seemed excessive to me.  I left the sugar out completely on the first taste test, but then decided it could use a little bit and added 1 tablespoon.  Here’s the recipe I used:

3 cups vanilla ice cream
1 cup cold coffee
1 cup milk
1 tablespoon sugar
3 tablespoons chocolate syrup

Combine the coffee, milk, and sugar in a blender. Then add the ice cream and the chocolate syrup and blend until creamy.

Possible Changes

  • To keep this shake thick and creamy, you may want to skip the blender. A watery shake is disappointing.
  • A little more ice cream might also help the consistency.
  • The stronger the coffee you use, the more intense your “mocha” flavor will be.

The flavor of this recipe is a close match to the real thing, but you need to be very mindful that it stays thick.
Final Grade: B+

Need a few more bright ideas?
Sign up for the monthly email newsletter to learn about my latest content and tips for frugal homemade living.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


  1. Did anybody notice that when you went to post it you had to take a test thingy that said “PLEASE PROVE THATV YOU ARE NOT A ROBOT” Haha (:

  2. I just made it but I used instant coffee. Normally you would put 1 tsp in a cup of water but I put 1 tsp in a 1/2 cup water. I only put 1/2 a cup of milk in it. I also put 2 tblsp of sugar and instead of chocolate syrup, I used Smucker's Special Recipe Hot Fudge. It turned out really good! Very close to a Jamocha Shake! It could still use some thickening but the flavor is awesome!

  3. I have found that adding just a little bit of instant pudding thickens shakes to that expected consistency of fast food places. They don't get watering that way at all.